• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • India
  • Business
  • Politics
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Technology
Waqf Amendment Act, Supreme Court, Chief Justice BR Gavai: Waqf Islamic Concept, But Not Essential Part Of Islam: Centre Defends Law

Waqf Amendment Act, Supreme Court, Chief Justice BR Gavai: Waqf Islamic Concept, But Not Essential Part Of Islam: Centre Defends Law

May 21, 2025
From dry cough to wheezing: Is air pollution actually sneaking up on your lungs? A pulmonologist shares 5 alarming signs you can't ignore

From dry cough to wheezing: Is air pollution actually sneaking up on your lungs? A pulmonologist shares 5 alarming signs you can’t ignore

November 18, 2026
Jeff Bezos says James Bond makers were initially ‘biased’ against Robert Pattinson due to his fame, claims he helped pick actor

Jeff Bezos says James Bond makers were initially ‘biased’ against Robert Pattinson due to his fame, claims he helped pick actor

November 18, 2026
Marco Rubio says ‘no imminent threat’ to US after reports of Iran’s ‘dirty bomb’ plot

Marco Rubio says ‘no imminent threat’ to US after reports of Iran’s ‘dirty bomb’ plot

November 18, 2026
Sensex opens over 100 points higher, Nifty above 25,300; Adani Ports, Asian Paints among top gainers

Sensex opens over 100 points higher, Nifty above 25,300; Adani Ports, Asian Paints among top gainers

November 17, 2026
Doctor explains link between perimenopause and brain fog: Understanding mental fatigue in the 40s

Doctor explains link between perimenopause and brain fog: Understanding mental fatigue in the 40s

November 17, 2026
Over 230 films to be screened at IFFI 2026 in Goa; Dhurandhar to open, Spain named Country of Honour

Over 230 films to be screened at IFFI 2026 in Goa; Dhurandhar to open, Spain named Country of Honour

November 17, 2026
Insider threats, network air gaps, secret rooms: The spycraft behind IAF chief's warning

Insider threats, network air gaps, secret rooms: The spycraft behind IAF chief’s warning

November 17, 2026
Ukraine war talks at China trilateral, meeting with Kim Jong Un likely: How Trump's Asia visit is taking shape

Ukraine war talks at China trilateral, meeting with Kim Jong Un likely: How Trump’s Asia visit is taking shape

November 17, 2026
Best of WTA 2026: The year Elena Rybakina's fitness finally matched her talent

Best of WTA 2026: The year Elena Rybakina’s fitness finally matched her talent

November 18, 2026
Dalal Street starts week higher as Sensex jumps over 400 points; IT, banks lead gains

Dalal Street starts week higher as Sensex jumps over 400 points; IT, banks lead gains

November 16, 2026
Breast cancer screening: Mammogram, ultrasound or MRI? Doctor explains which imaging test you need and when

Breast cancer screening: Mammogram, ultrasound or MRI? Doctor explains which imaging test you need and when

November 16, 2026
Scene worldwide box office collection day 9: Suriya's crime comedy overtakes Vishwanath & Sons to become his second highest-grossing film

Scene worldwide box office collection day 9: Suriya’s crime comedy overtakes Vishwanath & Sons to become his second highest-grossing film

November 16, 2026
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
No Result
View All Result
Daily News Broadcast India
  • India
    • All
    • Politics
    Insider threats, network air gaps, secret rooms: The spycraft behind IAF chief's warning

    Insider threats, network air gaps, secret rooms: The spycraft behind IAF chief’s warning

    Delhi AQI worsens to 323, IIT-Delhi records severe air quality as farm fires persist

    Delhi AQI worsens to 323, IIT-Delhi records severe air quality as farm fires persist

    Six coaches of Kolkata-Sairang Express derail at Digaru railway station in Assam; rescue ops on

    Six coaches of Kolkata-Sairang Express derail at Digaru railway station in Assam; rescue ops on

    Bengaluru cab driver kills wife, six of his in-laws; arrested: Police

    Bengaluru Cab Driver Kills Wife, Six Of His In-laws; Arrested: Police

    Rahul Gandhi’s ‘alcohol’ remark on Bhagwant Mann sharpens AAP-Congress tussle ahead of Punjab polls

    Rahul Gandhi’s ‘alcohol’ remark on Bhagwant Mann sharpens AAP-Congress tussle ahead of Punjab polls

    Delhi bar body calls for criminal action against suspended ACP for remarks against lawyers

    Delhi bar body calls for criminal action against suspended ACP for remarks against lawyers

    Rahul Gandhi rallies students for ‘Chalo Dilli’ march on November 1

    Rahul Gandhi rallies students for ‘Chalo Dilli’ march on November 1

    Nirmala Sitharaman, Rahul Gandhi spar over Tata leadership dispute: ‘Stop politicising every issue’

    Nirmala Sitharaman, Rahul Gandhi spar over Tata leadership dispute: ‘Stop politicising every issue’

    Uttar Pradesh Legislative Council polls: BJP wins 4, SP 1, ahead on 4 seats

    Uttar Pradesh Legislative Council polls: BJP wins 4, SP 1, ahead on 4 seats

    ‘System auto generated them’: Karnataka poll officials after 61,059 Form 7s filed without specific grounds

    ‘System auto generated them’: Karnataka poll officials after 61,059 Form 7s filed without specific grounds

    Trending Tags

    • Politics
  • Entertainment
    Jeff Bezos says James Bond makers were initially ‘biased’ against Robert Pattinson due to his fame, claims he helped pick actor

    Jeff Bezos says James Bond makers were initially ‘biased’ against Robert Pattinson due to his fame, claims he helped pick actor

    Over 230 films to be screened at IFFI 2026 in Goa; Dhurandhar to open, Spain named Country of Honour

    Over 230 films to be screened at IFFI 2026 in Goa; Dhurandhar to open, Spain named Country of Honour

    Scene worldwide box office collection day 9: Suriya's crime comedy overtakes Vishwanath & Sons to become his second highest-grossing film

    Scene worldwide box office collection day 9: Suriya’s crime comedy overtakes Vishwanath & Sons to become his second highest-grossing film

    Maatrubhumi trailer out: Salman Khan heads to the battlefield, takes on Chinese troops with a message of peace

    Maatrubhumi trailer out: Salman Khan heads to the battlefield, takes on Chinese troops with a message of peace

    ‘Maatrubhumi’ trailer: Salman Khan leads 200 Indian soldiers against a sea of Chinese troops in war actioner

    ‘Maatrubhumi’ trailer: Salman Khan leads 200 Indian soldiers against a sea of Chinese troops in war actioner

    Shah Rukh Khan admits struggling to remember Ed Sheeran's lyrics in King song Tu Mil Jaaye, praises daughter Suhana Khan for her effortless lip-sync

    Shah Rukh Khan admits struggling to remember Ed Sheeran’s lyrics in King song Tu Mil Jaaye, praises daughter Suhana Khan for her effortless lip-sync

    Jailer 2 box office collection day 21: Rajinikanth film slows down ahead of Ramayana release, earns ₹466 crore in 3 weeks

    Jailer 2 box office collection day 21: Rajinikanth film slows down ahead of Ramayana release, earns ₹466 crore in 3 weeks

    Suriya asks Lokesh Kanagaraj to call him to discuss stand-alone Rolex movie at Scene event; says he has played too many heroes

    Suriya asks Lokesh Kanagaraj to call him to discuss stand-alone Rolex movie at Scene event; says he has played too many heroes

    Jailer 2 box office collection day 19: Rajinikanth's film slows down, earns its lowest single-day haul on 3rd Monday

    Jailer 2 box office collection day 19: Rajinikanth’s film slows down, earns its lowest single-day haul on 3rd Monday

    Jailer 2 worldwide box office: Rajinikanth, 75, delivers Tamil cinema's first ₹800-crore blockbuster; film beats Chhaava, PK lifetime hauls

    Jailer 2 worldwide box office: Rajinikanth, 75, delivers Tamil cinema’s first ₹800-crore blockbuster; film beats Chhaava, PK lifetime hauls

  • Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Technology
  • World
  • Videos
  • Covid19
  • Opinion
DNB india
No Result
View All Result
Home India

Waqf Amendment Act, Supreme Court, Chief Justice BR Gavai: Waqf Islamic Concept, But Not Essential Part Of Islam: Centre Defends Law

by DNB ind News Desk
May 21, 2025
in India
0
Waqf Amendment Act, Supreme Court, Chief Justice BR Gavai: Waqf Islamic Concept, But Not Essential Part Of Islam: Centre Defends Law
2
SHARES
5
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare to Whatspp


Quick Read

Summary is AI generated, newsroom reviewed.

The Centre defended the Waqf Amendment Act in the Supreme Court, stating Waqf is not essential to Islam and emphasising its secular functions.

New Delhi:

Waqf is an Islamic concept, but it is not an essential part of Islam, the Centre told the Supreme Court today while defending the Waqf Amendment Act that has sparked protests and prompted a legal challenge. “Waqf is an Islamic concept, no doubt about it, but it is not an essential part of Islam. Waqf is not a fundamental right,” Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the Centre.

He said the government is the custodian of property of 140 crore citizens and it was the State’s duty to ensure that public property is not diverted illegally. “A false narrative is created that they will have to provide documents, or Waqf is captured en masse.”

Solicitor General Mehta said Waqf is for charity and a Waqf board only discharges secular functions. Countering the petitioners’ arguments against including non-Muslim members in Waqf bodies, he said, “Having 2 Non-Muslims, what will it change? It is not touching any religious activity.”

Earlier, Mr Mehta said a few petitioners cannot claim to represent the entire Muslim community. “We received 96 lakh representations. The JPC (Joint Parliamentary Committee) had 36 sittings. There were repeated deliberations with the JPC. They took various inputs from different Muslim bodies. Thereafter, a voluminous report was submitted, where suggestions were accepted/rejected with reasons. Then it was passed with unprecedented debate.”

On the subject of ‘waqf by user’, the Centre said that by definition, ‘waqf by user’ means the property belongs to someone else and you have acquired the right by continuous usage. “If there is a building which may be government property, can the government not examine whether the property belongs to the government?”

Countering the petitioners’ argument that the government cannot decide its own claim, Mr Mehta said the revenue authorities would decide whether it is government land, but they cannot decide the title.

Chief Justice BR Gavai said, “The picture that is being painted is that once the Collector conducts an inquiry, the property will cease to be a Waqf property and once the inquiry is complete, the entire property will be taken over by the government.” Mr Mehta replied that the government will have to file a title suit for ownership.

On the requirement that only a practising Muslim for five years can make a Waqf donation, Mr Mehta said, “Even Shariat has Section 3 that says you have to establish yourself as a Muslim. It does not mean you have to offer namaz 5 times a day or not drink wine etc. In some cases, difficulties have arisen regarding whether properties are subject to Waqf or not.”

Distinguishing between Hindu endowments and Waqf, Mr Mehta said the control over Hindu endowments is “pervasive”. “Hindu religious endowments are only religious. But Muslim Waqfs include many secular institutions like schools, madrasas, orphanages, dharamshalas etc,” he said.

Citing an example, he said the Bombay Public Trust Act governs temples in Maharashtra and its chairman can be of any religion.

Mr Mehta said a Waqf has two offices – one of the Sajjadanashin, who is the spiritual head and performs religious functions, and the second is the office of Mutawalli, who isthe administrator or manager. “First is not the subject of this Waqf case, because this law has nothing to do with religious and spiritual practice.”

Arguing that the law does not run contrary to Article 25 of the Constitution, which guarantees freedom of religion, the Solicitor General referred to the 1956 Hindu code bill that codified Hindu personal laws. “When Hindu Code Bill came in 1956, the personal law rights of Hindus, Christians, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains were taken away. No one said then why only Muslims were left and why others were not?”

The Solicitor General cited the Tamil Nadu Endowments Act that allows the Board to remove the Mathadhipati if he violates the rules of office. “And here we are arguing whether a microscopic minority in the Wakf Board will violate Articles 25, 26?”

What Petitioners Have Said

Hearing the petitioners’ arguments yesterday, Chief Justice of India BR Gavai said there is a presumption of constitutionality in legislation that clears Parliament and courts “cannot interfere unless a glaring case is made out”. The bench also comprises Justice AG Masih.

Appearing for a petitioner, Mr Sibal said the Act is aimed at capturing Waqf lands. “The law is designed in such a way that Waqf property is taken away without following any process.” He also pointed to the condition that only a person practising Islam for at least five years can create a Waqf. “If I am on my deathbed and I want to make a Waqf, I have to prove that I have been a practising Muslim. This is unconstitutional,” he said.

Mr Sibal said that under the new law, any village panchayat or a private individual can raise a grievance and the property ceases to be Waqf. “The government officer will decide it and will be a judge in his own cause. No questions asked.”

“Please remember that Waqf is about my property. It is only a property owned by someone and it cannot be of the State. Now that very property is taken away,” he said.

Mr Sibal also drew a comparison between mosques and temples. “Under our Constitution, the State cannot possibly finance religious institutions. The State cannot finance a mosque for its upkeep, a burial ground has to be made through private property. So people often at the end of life dedicate their properties as Waqf. There is no chadhava like in temples. Mosques and graveyards do not have Rs 2000-Rs 3000 crore corpus.” When the Chief Justice pointed out that grants are also made at dargahs, Mr Sibal said he was talking about mosques.


Source link

Related

Tags: Chief Justice of India BR GavaiSolicitor General Tushar MehtaWaqf Amendment Act
Share1Tweet1Send
DNB ind News Desk

DNB ind News Desk

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Yamaha MT-15 V2.0 launched in India, priced at Rs 1.60 lakh

Yamaha MT-15 V2.0 launched in India, priced at Rs 1.60 lakh

April 12, 2022
Shilpa Shetty to Tejasswi Prakash, These Stars Live Life Queen Size

Shilpa Shetty to Tejasswi Prakash, These Stars Live Life Queen Size

April 15, 2022
Saina Nehwal’s CWG and Asian Games title defense under threat due to THIS reason

Saina Nehwal’s CWG and Asian Games title defense under threat due to THIS reason

April 12, 2022

COVID-19 update: India records 7,579 new cases, 236 deaths in last 24 hours

0

Team India vice-captain Cheteshwar Pujara to carry ‘fearless mindset’ from England into NZ Tests

0

Breaking: Andhra Pradesh Assembly passes resolution, asks Centre for caste-based census of backward classes

0
From dry cough to wheezing: Is air pollution actually sneaking up on your lungs? A pulmonologist shares 5 alarming signs you can't ignore

From dry cough to wheezing: Is air pollution actually sneaking up on your lungs? A pulmonologist shares 5 alarming signs you can’t ignore

November 18, 2026
Jeff Bezos says James Bond makers were initially ‘biased’ against Robert Pattinson due to his fame, claims he helped pick actor

Jeff Bezos says James Bond makers were initially ‘biased’ against Robert Pattinson due to his fame, claims he helped pick actor

November 18, 2026
Marco Rubio says ‘no imminent threat’ to US after reports of Iran’s ‘dirty bomb’ plot

Marco Rubio says ‘no imminent threat’ to US after reports of Iran’s ‘dirty bomb’ plot

November 18, 2026
Daily News Broadcast India

Copyright © 2023 Daily News Broadcast India.

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • India
    • Politics
    • Business
    • World
  • Entertainment
    • Sports
  • Covid19
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Lifestyle

Copyright © 2023 Daily News Broadcast India.

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?